Simply Nourish Dog Food Alternatives

Published on
This post contains affiliate links, and we will be compensated if you buy after clicking on our links.
simply nourish

Simply Nourish is PetSmart’s brand of dog food. The brand focuses on wholesome ingredients, copious amounts of real meats and avoids artificial additives.

The dog food is sold primarily through PetSmart’s website, so it’s not as readily available at other retailers.

Our favorite alternative to Simply Nourish dog food is Merrick Classic Healthy Grains Real Chicken + Brown Rice Dog Food.

It’s filled with high-quality ingredients, with an excellent nutritional profile — and a price comparable to Simply Nourish dog food.

Read the rest of the article for other dog food similar to Simply Nourish and all the alternatives to their popular recipes.

Simply Nourish Dog Food Alternatives

  1. Merrick Classic Healthy Grains Real Chicken + Brown Rice Dod Food (Simply Nourish Natural Formula Alternative)
  2. CANIDAE PURE Limited Ingredient Salmon & Sweet Potato Dog Food (Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet Formula Alternative)
  3. Whole Earth Farms Chicken & Turkey Grain Free Dog Food (Simply Nourish Grain-Free Chicken Formula Alternative)
  4. Purina Pro Plan Weight Management Dog Food (Simply Nourish Healthy Weight Formula Alternative)
  5. Nutro Premium Loaf Beef, Sweet Potato & Carrot Canned Dog Food (Simply Nourish Shreds Wet Formula Alternative)

Dog Food Similar to Simply Nourish Reviewed

Simply Nourish dog food range features dry dog food and canned food.

The brand covers dogs’ different dietary needs: complete and balanced nutrition, limited ingredients, diets, grain-free options, and weight management formulas.

They are committed to using whole meats, healthy whole grains or adequate grain substitutes, and fresh fruits and veggies.

Regarding the price, this dog food falls into the mid-range category.

Let’s look at dog foods comparable to Simply Nourish in more detail.

Merrick Classic Healthy Grains Real Chicken + Brown Rice Dog Food

Merrick Classic Healthy Grains Real Chicken

Merrick is a premium dog food brand that uses human-grade ingredients in all the formulas. The company is trusted by many pet parents and even offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

Merrick’s Healthy Grains Chicken recipe includes real chicken meat and healthy whole grains, so it’s comparable to Simply Nourish Natural, Chicken & Brown Rice.

The recipes are similar in price, but Merrick offers a bigger selection of whole grains and animal protein sources.

Both formulas include deboned chicken and chicken meal as animal protein sources for similar levels of proteins, complete amino acid profile, and additional minerals.

The Merrick formula also has turkey meal and salmon meal for an extra burst of taste and healthy Omega-3 fatty acids.

Merrick’s recipe sports an impressive selection of whole grains and ancient grains, like brown rice, barley, oats, and quinoa. These provide energy, dietary fiber, and extra vitamins and minerals.

This dog food also includes fresh fruits and probiotics for a stronger immune system and healthier digestion.

CANIDAE PURE Limited Ingredient Salmon & Sweet Potato Dog Food

CANIDAE Grain-Free PURE LID Salmon

Canidae is a small dog food brand with a stellar reputation for premium ingredients. They are primarily known for their high-quality limited ingredient diets.

Is your dog allergic to some of the animal proteins and needs LID? Canidae dog food is comparable in price to the Simply Nourish Limited Ingredient Diet but offers more good stuff.

Both recipes start with deboned salmon and salmon meal, yet Canidae also adds menhaden fish meal as the third ingredient.

This makes up for a significant increase in animal protein — Canidae sports 32% of crude protein, compared to Simply Nourish’s 26%. So your dog’s muscles and joints get much more support.

Extra fish also brings in additional Omega-3s. Omega-3 fatty acids are super important in limited ingredient diets since they nourish skin, promote the immune system, and take care of heart health.

The recipe also includes probiotics which improve digestion and alleviate stomach issues.

Like many grain-free formulas, Canidae contains taurine for added support to vision and heart health.

Whole Earth Farms Chicken & Turkey Dog Food

Whole Earth Farms Grain Free Chicken Turkey Dry

If you want a grain-free alternative to Simply Nourish Adut Chicken Recipe, Whole Earth Farms might just be the thing.

The biggest difference between these two formulas is the quality of grain substitutes. Simply Nourish mainly uses dried peas and dried potatoes as primary carb sources. On the other hand, Whole Earth Farm opts for canola meal, fresh peas, and fresh sweet potatoes. These bring in extra proteins and dietary fiber, vitamins, and minerals.

We especially like that Whole Earth Farms doesn’t stop there but adds fresh, antioxidant-rich apples and carrots filled with beta-carotene. They support the immune system, bring in additional vitamins, and contribute to skin and vision health.

The macronutrient profile of these formulas is similar, with protein content in both formulas at 27%. This is more than enough support for your furry friend’s muscles.

Fiber is lower in Whole Earth Farms, which is a good thing. Grain-free peas and legumes are notorious for causing flatulence, and 3.5% fiber shouldn’t cause any significant digestive distress.

Purina Pro Plan Weight Management Dog Food

Purina Pro Plan Adult Weight Management Shredded Blend Chicken

So your big doggie needs to shed some pounds? In that case, Purina Pro Plan is a tried-and-tested solution and a great alternative to Simply Nourish Healthy Weight.

Managing weight is tricky, because you need to find the sweet spot between losing weight and still getting all the nutrients.

That’s why Purina Pro Plan offers a protein-to-fat ratio that supports weight loss while maintaining healthy body composition and muscle mass.

The proteins come from a high-quality whole chicken, poultry by-product meal, and fish meal. Poultry introduces glucosamine sulfate, which supports dogs’ joints and cartilage. The fish meal brings in Omega-3s for cardiovascular health.

And — not to get too technical — but your dog might just love losing fat by enjoying the beef fat in this recipe. Healthy and tasty.

The formula also includes natural prebiotic fiber and live probiotics, which soothe the stomach. They are super important for weight loss because they promote efficient digestion and proper absorption of nutrients.

Nutro Premium Loaf Beef, Sweet Potato & Carrot Canned Dog Food

Nutro Premium Loaf Adult Tender Beef

Nutro dog food brand is non-GMO, free of additives and by-products. The company focuses on natural ingredients while keeping the prices affordable.

Nutro canned food can be a great alternative to Simply Nourish Shreds Wet Food. Both formulas are grain-free and provide complete nutrition for your canine.

Both recipes start with beef and beef broth. However, unlike Simply Nourish, Nutro also includes whole chicken and beef liver for added taste, minerals, and proteins. While the liver doesn’t sound too appetizing to us, dogs generally love to gobble up this organ meat.

Your furry family member will also enjoy the added veggie goodness. The dog food contains sweet potatoes, carrots, and peas.

These bring in antioxidants, beta-carotene, vitamins, dietary fiber, and minerals. The energy from these carbs is slowly released, providing your dog with enough vigor throughout the day.

The savory loaf texture of the food makes it a suitable topper or standalone food.

How to Transition to a New Food

Once you choose a new dog food similar to Simply Nourish, you can start introducing it to your dog’s kibble.

Do we mean you shouldn’t just switch it entirely overnight? Ideally, you shouldn’t, since doing that might give your dog stomach problems.

Instead, do this: start by mixing in 25% of the new food with your dog’s kibble. Every 2-3 days, you can increase the proportion by an additional 25%. This way, you should switch your dog’s food entirely in about 10 days.

If your dog shows symptoms of digestive issues, decrease the amount of the new food. After some time, you can try increasing the ratio again.

However, if the problems persist, it’s best to talk to the vet.

Our Verdict

Simply Nourish is an excellent, premium-quality dog food with many high-quality ingredients.

If you’re looking for a great alternative, we highly recommend the Merrick Classic Healthy Grains Real Chicken + Brown Rice Dog Food.

This dog food is in a similar price range but has a variety of animal protein sources and a bigger selection of great, healthy whole grains. They are bound to provide your dog with the great nutrients your canine deserves.

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 5 / 5. Vote count: 1

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

As you found this post useful...

Follow us on social media!

We are sorry that this post was not useful for you!

Let us improve this post!

Tell us how we can improve this post?

Photo of author
As a dog breeder's daughter, I've always been surrounded by many dogs of many breeds. I've made it my job to learn about our furry best friends and share my findings with other conscious dog owners. My Bichon is called Piper by the way :)

Save 30% on your next dog food order!

We have partnered with to offer the best deal on high-quality dog food to our readers. If you click on the button below, we will take you to their exclusive discount page.